The Kingdom Too Large for Our Hands

Rome killed them. We built basilicas.

I find this an astonishing arrangement, even for Catholics, who can turn a martyr’s grave into an architectural undertaking lasting several pontificates. On November 18, we commemorate the dedication of the basilicas of Saints Peter and Paul: immense churches honoring two men whose apostolic authority came with no army to keep them alive. The marble came later. First came the surrender.

Peter had denied knowing Jesus. Paul had persecuted his followers. Neither résumé suggests that these were the men to whom one should entrust the future. Yet here we are, remembering their names while the emperors who killed Christians have become examination questions. Rome possessed the instruments of execution. The apostles carried news of a resurrection.

I love the buildings. Beauty can bring us to our knees before we know we need to kneel. But their splendor asks a question I would sometimes rather admire the ceiling than answer: Do I want the Church to be faithful, or do I want her to look successful?

I know how quickly I can confuse the two.

Constantine’s favor brought Christians relief from persecution and room to worship publicly. These were blessings. Nobody should have to lose a child to an executioner so that later generations can enjoy an inspiring account of the early Church. Freedom matters. So do hospitals, universities, schools, and the patient institutional work by which love acquires a roof and a payroll.

But imperial favor carried its own temptation: to mistake the emperor’s welcome for the Lord’s approval.

Jesus told Pilate, “My kingdom does not belong to this world.” He was not declaring the world beneath his concern. He was standing inside its machinery of violence, refusing to borrow its definition of kingship. His kingdom does not derive its authority from the power to compel. Its King gives himself away.

We have needed repeated instruction.

In 756, Pepin’s donation helped establish the Papal States. The arrangement offered protection and independence; it also entangled Peter’s successors in territorial rule. Popes crowned emperors, contested loyalties, defended possessions. Sometimes the shepherd’s staff became difficult to distinguish from a royal scepter.

In 897, Pope Stephen VI had the corpse of Pope Formosus exhumed and tried.

Catholics are often accused of being unable to let things go. Here the evidence is uncomfortable.

But the laughter catches. Someone ordered the grave opened. Someone dressed the body. Human beings entrusted with holy things allowed hatred to become a public ceremony. Centuries later, the Western Schism left Christians divided among rival papal claimants, eventually three. Imagine trying to teach a child what communion means while the grown-ups disputed which pope to obey.

Through these failures, the Eucharist was still celebrated, saints still served, and grace still worked. None of that made the failures less terrible. It made the betrayal more terrible.

Then, in September 1870, Italian troops captured Rome, ending the Papal States.

The Church did not end with them.

In 1891, Leo XIII addressed the industrial world through Rerum Novarum, defending workers’ dignity and helping lay the foundations of modern Catholic social teaching. The papacy had lost its territorial kingdom; it had not lost its responsibility for the world.

Nor did that loss cause everything good that followed. Catholic life has spread through missionary courage, local leadership, families, cultures, migration, and demographic change, sometimes entangled with colonial coercion and grave injustice. History will not fit our favorite sermon quite so neatly. Still, 1870 exposed something worth remembering: the Gospel had never needed a frontier.

Neither does this mean the Church is an invisible fellowship with unfortunate administrative attachments. She is a visible, sacramental communion, with bishops, authority, obligations, buildings, and bills. Christ works through these earthly realities. Their purpose is to gather people into his life, not to make his servants untouchable.

The sexual abuse crisis reveals the horror of forgetting that purpose. Children were abused. Survivors were disbelieved. Leaders protected perpetrators and institutional reputations instead of vulnerable people. These were not merely wounds inflicted upon the Church. These were wounds inflicted by her members and deepened by failures of authority. No account of our endurance can substitute for truth, justice, safeguarding, and care.

I cannot consider that history honestly while making institutional self-protection someone else’s temptation.

I, too, can want a ministry to succeed so badly that I stop asking what conversion requires of me. I can prefer a reassuring attendance figure to an uncomfortable conversation. I can want the Church publicly vindicated because I am tired of feeling foolish for loving her.

And I understand the fear beneath our hunger for influence. People worry about their children, their freedom, the disappearance of a familiar world. They deserve tenderness, not ridicule. But are we becoming so frightened of losing influence that we have forgotten the apostles’ confidence? Do we spend more energy trying to win the world than trying to love it?

Across Africa, Asia, the Americas, Europe, and Oceania, approximately 1.4 billion Catholics belong to this wounded communion. Numbers cannot measure holiness. Communities shrink; others grow. Some people have left because we failed them terribly.

Yet today someone will receive baptism. Someone will carry Communion to a person who can no longer swallow ordinary food. Someone will sit beside the dying after everyone else has gone home.

The point is not that Catholicism always wins.

The point is that Christ remains faithful.

Which brings me back to those two basilicas, and those two difficult, beloved men. Peter and Paul disagreed. Their unity was not a resemblance of temperament. It was belonging to Christ, surrendering their lives to the Gospel he had entrusted to them.

Our communion likewise requires apostolic faith, not matching opinions about every earthly question. We cannot make doctrine disposable. Neither can we make a political allegiance an additional article of the Creed. The Church proclaims and serves the Kingdom; she is its beginning on earth, not a baptized empire built to satisfy our anxieties.

I imagine the apostles beneath those enormous roofs, though I cannot imagine what they would make of the maintenance budget. The buildings are not the Kingdom. Their beauty points beyond itself, toward the Lord who made their fearful, stubborn hearts spacious enough for strangers.

Today I can help make room: call the Catholic I have reduced to an argument, pray for the one whose opinions exhaust me, serve someone who cannot improve my prospects, speak the name of Jesus without arranging for someone else to lose. We were promised no empire, only that Christ would remain with us. That is enough to open the doors. Let the fisherman and the former persecutor have their marble; somewhere nearby, there is a chair we can pull out for someone who thought there was no place for them.

Next
Next

There Is Still a Place for You at This Table